Once upon a time, Conchahocken was a blue collar, wrong-side-of-the-tracks ‘burb of Philadelphia. But no longer. Thanks to some stylish urban upgrading, the 19th century neighborhood now offers a lot for visiting diners.
Blackfish, brainchild of chef Charles “Chip” Roman, is the noisy home of some of the most creative cooking I’ve ever tasted in this country. Roman was most recently sous-chef at Le Bec Fin, where he studied for many years with Philadelphia’s George Perrier. It shows. But so does Roman’s own impish expertise with very fresh, very pretty flavor combinations. Six of us sampled a substantial cross-section of the early spring menu at Blackfish last week, and - noise aside - we were impressed. (i.e. blown away).
Our dinner started off with an amuse of intensely sweet/tart beet gastrique, served to each of us on individual spoons. A sexy start. Very service-intensive, the long corridor of dining rooms was packed by 8pm, with waiters busily opening wine
bottles. Blackfish is BYOB, no corkage, so we laid out an array of Chilean cabernets and Australian shiraz to accompany our dinner. My wine tip for you is to hunt down Casillero del Diablo 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, from Concha y Toro, produced from grapes from Chile’s Maipo Valley. Two appetizer soups of pureed fresh carrot gazpacho and tangy green herb were poured into huge bowls from vintage tea pots. A trio of day boat scallops sat on a pillow of trumpet mushrooms, surrounded by a circular necklace of balsamic reduction thick as jam.
My appetizer left me practically speechless. As beautiful as it was innovative, it involved a small, creamy pyramid of parmesan panna cotta. This was adorned by a crisp savory tuile, cubes of roasted ruby beets and pickled ramps, a local delicacy this time of year. A fluff of daikon sprouts crowned the beets and across the width of the plate a rich, glaze of blackberry reduction. Try to imagine these flavors all conspiring — the creamy, cheese custard, pungent wild leeks, and deep purple berry juice. (The idea of a savory, appetizer panna cotta has taken east coast restaurants by storm, for example Per Se is currently running a cauliflower panna cotta on its ultra-pricey tasting menu.)
The beauty of Roman’s approach is his sensitivity to the role of very fresh, specifically chosen vegetables —light-years away from the idea of “side dish.” His care with imaginative produce gives them a starring role on each plate. They are part of the conceptual design, and not just an obligatory accompaniment.
Entrees also brought surprising flavor strategies. A square of perfectly pan-roasted Alaskan halibut arrived with a rhubarb puree and tart verjus emulsion. Another dish of red snapper offered infant fava beans, baby squashs in a small pool of star anise broth. Long Island duck breast fanned out over a fresh stew of various shell beans and favas, sided with house-made duck sausage. My roasted line-caught striped bass sat on a bed of crisp asparagus and trumpet mushrooms, framed by an emulsion perfumed with curry. This dish was elegant as well as effortless to enjoy — the buttery, moist fish was a sumptuous match for the delicate asparagus and ethereal froth of curry. Mother of God.
Two desserts and six spoons arrived — one a perfect lemon tart (pictured above) ringed by fresh berries and a thin curl of dark chocolate, the other a radical creation of pistachio creme brulée topped with freshly-whipped cream. For some at our table, the delicious custard tasted “too much like peanut butter.” But I thought it was daring and wonderful. The entire dinner was a tribute to Springtime in the northeast of North America. With some carpeting and some wall coverings - perhaps a line-up of original artwork - the nighttime noise level of Blackfish might lower to the point of comfort. Even though I was unable to hear any of my companions’ conversations throughout dinner, the food was sensational. Fresh, sexy, utterly surprising — exactly what imaginative dining should be. Blackfish. When in Philly……